- 21-Dec-2024
- Family Law Guides
Yes, interim orders issued during divorce proceedings can be challenged under certain circumstances. Interim orders are temporary orders given by the court during the course of the divorce proceedings to provide immediate relief on specific matters like maintenance, child custody, visitation rights, or alimony. While these orders are not final judgments, they are enforceable and can significantly affect the parties involved.
In India, the law allows for challenges to interim orders, but such challenges are generally subject to certain conditions and timelines.
If a party is dissatisfied with an interim order issued by a Family Court, they have the option to file an appeal. Under Section 19 of the Family Courts Act, 1984, any party aggrieved by an order passed by a family court can appeal to the High Court. This appeal must be filed within 30 days from the date of the order. The appeal should be based on valid legal grounds, such as:
Under Section 114 of the Code of Civil Procedure (CPC), a party can file a review petition in the same court that passed the interim order. A review petition seeks to bring to the court’s attention new evidence or points of law that were not considered during the original hearing. The review petition is typically heard by the same judge who passed the original order. However, the grounds for review are narrow, such as a clerical mistake, error on the face of the record, or newly discovered evidence.
The court itself has the discretion to reconsider its interim orders. If there is a significant change in circumstances, or if new evidence arises, either party may request the court to review or modify the interim order. For instance, if a parent’s financial situation improves or worsens after a maintenance order, they may request the court to revise the amount.
If a party believes that the family court does not have the jurisdiction to issue a particular interim order (for example, if the court lacks authority to rule on child custody in an interstate divorce case), they may file a jurisdictional challenge. However, such challenges may be difficult to succeed unless the issue of jurisdiction is clear and obvious.
If the interim order involves a fundamental issue of law (such as constitutional issues or matters that violate the fundamental rights of an individual), the aggrieved party may approach the Supreme Court of India directly under Article 136 of the Indian Constitution, which allows special leave petitions.
An appeal against an interim order is typically filed with the High Court under Section 19 of the Family Courts Act, but it must be done within the prescribed time limit (usually 30 days). The appellant must show that the family court erred in its judgment. During the appeal process, the higher court may either uphold the interim order, modify it, or set it aside, depending on the merits of the case.
If the party wants the same court to reconsider its decision, they may file a review petition. This petition must be filed within a reasonable period after the order is passed. The grounds for review include errors in facts, law, or judgment. A review petition has a narrower scope and does not typically entertain fresh evidence unless there is something that was not available earlier.
If a party’s circumstances change significantly after the interim order (such as a sudden loss of income, illness, or a change in the child’s needs), they can request the court to modify the interim order. The modification request must be supported by solid evidence showing that the change in circumstances justifies altering the terms of the interim order.
If the party challenging the interim order believes that its implementation will cause irreparable harm or that it is unjust, they may apply for a stay of the order. The higher court will consider whether staying the order is in the interest of justice and will likely give its decision within a short time frame.
To challenge an interim order, the party must show that there is a prima facie case of injustice or error in the initial order. Simply disagreeing with the order is not enough; there must be legal grounds for modification or appeal.
The courts will also consider whether there is a balance of convenience in favor of granting the challenge. If modifying or staying the interim order would cause undue harm or inconvenience to the other party, the court may decide against granting the challenge.
If the implementation of the interim order would cause irreparable harm to the challenging party (for example, if a maintenance order is too high or an interim child custody order is unfair), the party can argue that the harm outweighs the need to maintain the order.
If the interim order involves child custody or visitation, the court will always consider the best interests of the child as the paramount factor when deciding whether to grant a modification or stay.
Suppose a husband in a divorce proceeding is ordered to pay a significant amount in interim maintenance to his wife, but he believes this amount is disproportionate to his income. He can file an appeal with the High Court challenging the interim maintenance order. In his appeal, he provides evidence of his reduced income and financial difficulties, requesting the court to lower the amount of maintenance. The High Court will review the case and may either uphold the family court’s order, modify the maintenance amount, or set it aside entirely based on the merits of the appeal.
Yes, interim orders in divorce proceedings can be challenged, but such challenges must be based on valid legal grounds. The aggrieved party can appeal the order to a higher court, file a review petition, or request the modification of the order if there has been a significant change in circumstances. The legal process for challenging interim orders involves proving that the order was unjust or erroneous, and in cases involving child custody or maintenance, the best interests of the child and the welfare of both parties are always central considerations for the court.
Answer By Law4u Team
Discover clear and detailed answers to common questions about Family Law Guides. Learn about procedures and more in straightforward language.
