Disputes over property gifted by parents can arise due to various reasons, including misunderstandings about the intention of the gift, challenges to the validity of the gift, or conflicts among family members. The law in India addresses these disputes by considering the legal validity of the gift, the intentions of the parents, and the applicable inheritance laws.
For a property to be legally considered as a gift, a gift deed must be executed, and the property must be transferred during the lifetime of the donor (the parent). This deed should be signed by both the donor and the donee (the recipient of the gift) and should be witnessed. A properly executed gift deed, when registered, legally transfers the property to the donee, and the donor no longer has ownership rights over the property. If the gift deed is not registered, disputes may arise about the legitimacy of the gift.
The key to resolving disputes over gifted property is to understand the intentions of the parent (the donor). If there is a clear, documented intention to gift the property, the recipient (donee) can assert their rights. However, if there is no formal documentation or if the gift was made under duress or without the full understanding of the donor’s intentions, disputes can arise. Courts often look at the circumstances under which the gift was made to determine whether the intent was to gift the property outright or to retain control over it.
While a gift deed executed without registration can still be valid, registered gifts are much less likely to face legal challenges. For immovable property (such as land or a house), registration is generally mandatory to ensure the transfer is legally recognized. If the property was not formally registered, the donee may have difficulty asserting ownership, especially if other family members dispute the validity of the gift.
Disputes often arise when other family members feel excluded from receiving a share of the property. In cases where parents have gifted property to one child, siblings may contest the gift, particularly if they believe the parents intended to divide the property equally among all children or if there is no clear evidence of the parent’s intentions. Under Hindu Succession Act, if the property was inherited by the parents, the children (including the one who received the gift) could still have a claim to the property, depending on whether the parent was the absolute owner and the nature of the gift.
Revocation of a gift by the donor is another complex area. In general, a gift made during the lifetime of the donor cannot be easily revoked unless it was done under a condition of revocation or if the donor faces certain legal grounds such as fraud, coercion, or undue influence. Parents may wish to revoke the gift if they feel the donee has not honored their wishes, but this process can be complicated and requires proper legal action.
If the gift was made without due consideration or the legal requirements (such as a formal gift deed), the property may still be considered part of the parent’s estate upon their death. In this case, the children, especially those not receiving the gift, may claim a share based on inheritance laws. For instance, under the Hindu Succession Act, children are entitled to an equal share in the ancestral property, which may include property the parents had intended to gift.
Mediation and arbitration are common methods used to resolve property disputes among family members without resorting to litigation. Courts encourage settlement of disputes through alternative methods like mediation, especially in family disputes, to preserve relationships. However, if mediation fails, the dispute can proceed to litigation, where the court will review the validity of the gift, the donor's intentions, and other relevant factors to make a decision.
If a parent gifts a house to one of their children while alive, but after the parent's death, the other children claim that the gift was made under duress or that the gift was not properly documented, the matter can be taken to court. The court will examine whether there was a valid gift deed, whether the gift was registered, and the intentions of the parent at the time of the gift. If the gift was executed correctly, the donee (the child who received the gift) will have a stronger legal claim to the property.
In property disputes involving gifts from parents, the law considers various factors, including the validity of the gift, the intentions of the parents, and the legal formalities followed in the transfer. A gift deed that is properly executed and registered provides clarity and minimizes the chances of disputes. However, if there are ambiguities or if family members feel the gift was made under undue influence or coercion, disputes can arise. To avoid such conflicts, parents should ensure proper documentation and registration of gifts and, if possible, communicate their intentions clearly to all heirs.
Answer By Law4u Team
Discover clear and detailed answers to common questions about Family Law Guides. Learn about procedures and more in straightforward language.
