- 19-Apr-2025
- Healthcare and Medical Malpractice
Cross-border surrogacy, or international surrogacy, involves intended parents from one country and a surrogate mother from another, or a surrogate mother carrying a child for intended parents who are citizens of different countries. While this arrangement offers various opportunities for those seeking surrogacy services, it presents significant legal challenges due to the differences in national laws, the recognition of parenthood, and citizenship issues. The legal uncertainties surrounding parental rights, immigration, and child’s nationality can complicate the surrogacy process, and in some cases, may result in prolonged legal battles.
a. Differences in National Laws:
Surrogacy laws vary significantly from country to country. While some countries have comprehensive surrogacy laws that regulate the rights and responsibilities of all parties involved, others may have no legal framework or outright ban surrogacy. This can create a legal void or contradictions when surrogacy takes place across borders.
In some countries, commercial surrogacy (surrogacy for financial compensation) is illegal, while in others, it is permitted or regulated. For example, while India used to be a popular destination for commercial surrogacy for foreign couples, it has recently passed the Surrogacy (Regulation) Bill, 2020, which restricts commercial surrogacy and only permits it for Indian couples. This has led many international couples to seek surrogacy services in countries like the United States, Ukraine, or Georgia, where surrogacy is legal.
b. Lack of International Legal Recognition:
There is no single, unified international law governing cross-border surrogacy. As a result, legal recognition of parental rights and the child’s nationality can become a challenge when the intended parents seek to have the child recognized in their home country. Some countries may refuse to recognize the intended parents as the legal parents, especially if the child was born to a surrogate mother in a country with different legal standards.
For example, intended parents may face legal hurdles when seeking to obtain a birth certificate that reflects their parentage, particularly if the surrogate mother’s name is listed as the mother on the birth certificate or if disputes arise over parental rights.
a. Parental Rights Recognition:
In some countries, the legal parentage of a child born via surrogacy is automatically recognized as belonging to the intended parents. In others, the surrogate mother may initially be listed as the legal parent, and the intended parents must undergo a legal process (such as adoption or a parentage order) to establish their legal rights to the child. This can be particularly problematic when cross-border surrogacy involves countries with differing legal frameworks.
For example, in the United Kingdom, intended parents can apply for a Parental Order after the child’s birth to become the legal parents, whereas in the United States, the intended parents’ rights are generally clear from the outset, assuming the correct legal steps are followed.
b. Citizenship and Immigration Complications:
Citizenship and immigration are two of the most significant legal challenges in cross-border surrogacy cases. The child’s nationality may be unclear at birth, as the country where the child is born may not automatically grant citizenship to a child born via surrogacy.
Furthermore, intended parents may face complications in obtaining the necessary immigration visas to bring the child back to their home country. Different countries have different rules for citizenship by descent, and in some cases, the child may not be automatically entitled to citizenship in the parents’ home country.
In some cases, countries like Canada, France, and Germany do not recognize commercial surrogacy and may refuse to grant citizenship to a child born through such an arrangement. This can lead to lengthy immigration and legal battles to secure the child's status.
a. Exploitation Concerns:
One of the ethical challenges of cross-border surrogacy is the potential for exploitation of surrogate mothers, especially in countries where surrogacy is poorly regulated or where financial compensation may be disproportionately large. In some developing countries, surrogates may be economically vulnerable, and this raises concerns about the ethicality of using surrogacy as a commercial service.
Intended parents and agencies involved in cross-border surrogacy must carefully evaluate the ethical implications and ensure that surrogate mothers are properly compensated, fully informed, and not coerced into participating in the surrogacy arrangement.
b. Psychological Impact on the Surrogate and Child:
Surrogates in cross-border surrogacy arrangements may experience psychological or emotional challenges, particularly if they are far from the intended parents and the process is not well-supported. In some cases, surrogates may not have adequate access to healthcare, mental health support, or legal protections.
The child born via surrogacy may face questions of identity and parentage in the future, especially if they are born in a country where surrogacy laws are not as clearly defined, or if their parental rights are questioned later on.
Example 1: A British couple enters into a commercial surrogacy arrangement in India, where surrogacy was previously legal for foreign couples. However, due to changes in Indian law, they are now unable to take the child home without a parentage order or facing lengthy court proceedings to establish their legal parenthood.
Example 2: A Canadian couple uses a surrogate in the United States to have a child, but upon birth, the U.S. government refuses to issue a birth certificate listing the intended parents as the parents. The couple is now caught in an immigration dispute, as the child’s citizenship status is unclear, and they cannot bring the child back to Canada without proving their legal relationship.
Cross-border surrogacy presents complex legal challenges related to parental rights, citizenship, immigration, and recognition of parentage due to the lack of a unified international framework governing surrogacy. These challenges are further exacerbated by differences in national laws and the ethical concerns surrounding commercial surrogacy in certain countries. Intended parents considering cross-border surrogacy should carefully navigate these legal complexities by consulting with legal experts and ensuring that the process is conducted ethically and in compliance with the laws of both the country of the surrogate mother and the country of the intended parents. Furthermore, international collaborations or agreements on surrogacy could provide more clarity and protection for all parties involved.
Answer By Law4u Team
Discover clear and detailed answers to common questions about Family Law Guides. Learn about procedures and more in straightforward language.
