Home
Legal Advice
Insurance
How does the law handle cases involving the liability of insurance companies for delayed claim settlements?

How does the law handle cases involving the liability of insurance companies for delayed claim settlements?

02-Dec-2024

Insurance

Answer By law4u team

In India, the law provides various mechanisms for addressing cases involving the liability of insurance companies for delayed claim settlements. The key legal provisions that govern this issue include: The Insurance Act, 1938: Obligation of Timely Settlement: The Insurance Act mandates that insurance companies settle claims within a reasonable time. Although it doesn't specify an exact timeframe, the principle of fair and prompt settlement is implied, and delays can lead to penalties or claims of unfair practices. Regulation by IRDAI: The Insurance Regulatory and Development Authority of India (IRDAI) oversees insurance practices in India and has issued guidelines to ensure timely settlement of claims. Insurers are required to acknowledge claims within 15 days and settle claims within 30 days (for most types of claims), or 45 days in the case of some specialized claims. IRDAI Guidelines and Circulars: Timely Settlement Rules: IRDAI prescribes that insurance companies must acknowledge receipt of a claim within 15 days and must settle claims within 30 days of receiving all the required documentation. For more complex claims, this period can extend up to 45 days. Interest for Delayed Settlement: IRDAI has also issued guidelines that require insurers to pay interest for any delayed settlement of claims. The interest payable is generally calculated from the date of receipt of the complete documentation to the date of settlement, and the rate of interest is usually the bank rate plus 2%. Consumer Protection Act, 2019: Consumer Forums and Redressal: If an insurance company delays or denies a claim without valid reasons, the policyholder can approach the consumer forum under the Consumer Protection Act, 2019. The law provides consumers with the right to seek redressal for grievances, including delayed claim settlements, and can result in compensation for the delay. Compensation for Delay: Consumer forums can direct the insurance company to settle the claim and may also award compensation for the inconvenience, harassment, or financial loss caused by the delay. Civil Liability: Breach of Contract: An insurance policy is essentially a contract between the insurer and the insured. If an insurer fails to settle a claim within a reasonable time, it could be seen as a breach of contract. The policyholder may file a civil suit against the insurer for the claim amount along with interest and damages. Damages for Delay: If the delay causes significant financial or emotional hardship to the claimant, they may seek additional damages beyond the claim amount, depending on the circumstances. Standard Operating Procedures (SOPs) by Insurers: Many insurance companies have adopted Standard Operating Procedures (SOPs) that outline the process and timelines for claim settlement. If an insurance company fails to follow these SOPs or causes unnecessary delays, they may be penalized by IRDAI, and the policyholder may be entitled to compensation. Court Rulings: Judicial Interventions: The courts in India have, in several cases, directed insurance companies to pay compensation for delayed claim settlements. Courts have ruled that insurers must not unreasonably delay the settlement of claims and that policyholders are entitled to receive their dues promptly. Supreme Court Rulings: In cases like United India Insurance Co. Ltd. vs. Laxmi Narain Dhut (2007), the Supreme Court has observed that insurers should act in good faith and settle claims within a reasonable time. A delay without valid reasons may result in the insurer being liable to pay interest on the claim amount. Penalties for Non-Compliance: Fines by IRDAI: The Insurance Regulatory and Development Authority of India (IRDAI) can impose fines on insurance companies for failing to adhere to the timelines for claim settlement. The penalties may include a fine or even suspension of operations if the non-compliance is found to be habitual. In conclusion, the law in India provides multiple avenues for policyholders to seek relief in cases of delayed insurance claim settlements. Insurance companies are legally obligated to settle claims promptly, and if they fail to do so, they can face penalties, interest payments, and consumer grievances redressal through forums and courts.

Answer By Ayantika Mondal

Dear Client, Typically, insurance companies face liabilities associated with delayed claims settlement, using varied legal structures and regulatory frameworks that guard the policyholder's interests while at the same time availing him compensation. Legal Provisions relating to Delayed Claim Settlements 1. Insurance Act, 1938 The settlement of claims under the Insurance Act provides that: • Section 64VB: It states that settlement of the claim should be done within 30 days from receipt of all required documents. • Section 13 provides that in the event of failure by an insurer to pay a claim amount within the stipulated time, interest shall be carried on the amount from the date when the amount became due to the date of settlement. 2. Regulatory oversight by IRDAI The Insurance Regulatory and Development Authority of India has developed detailed guidelines that are to be followed in expediting claim settlements. • Insurers must respond within 15 days, and judgment must be given within 30 days on the claim. • If more time is required, the insurers must inform the insured for the reasons of delay. 3. Consumer Protection Mechanisms Policyholders may seek redressal through several consumer protection avenues • In case of delay considered to be a deficiency of service, complaint may be lodged before Consumer Disputes Redressal Commission and further may direct to pay with interest and compensation of mental agony or unfair trade practice. •Besides, complaint can be lodged with Insurance Ombudsman whose disputes settle usually in the period of three months specially it relates to settlement of claim. Implications of Delayed Settlements This could strain the finances of the policyholder due to late payment. Some of the strategies which the providers use for delay are: • Intentionally delaying payment so that the claimants are forced to negotiate settlements based on their need. • Generating interest on unpaid claims, thereby benefiting financially from holding onto funds longer than necessary Legal Recourse If initial remedies do not work, policyholders can seek further legal action; they may approach civil courts where judges can award the claim amount along with interest for delays and may even add damages to insurers for wrongful delays. Conclusion The law offers sound mechanisms by which it deals with delays experienced in settling insurance claims while making sure the insurer delivers its promise. Policyholders find recourse in regulatory bodies, consumer protection forums thus making delayed payments not as serious an issue. Hope this answer helps you.

Answer By Anik

Dear Client, Liability on delayed settlement of claims to policyholders regarding insurance companies directly has remedies and various mechanisms in the laws. 1. Regulatory Framework for Claim Settlement • Timing of Settlements: Settle claims as per the proviso of the Insurance law and regulation. In India, it is mandatory, according to the Indian Insurance Regulatory and Development Authority, to settle claims within 30 days after the receiving of all documents required. • Should the insurer neglect to adhere to these specified timelines, regulatory authorities possess the ability to levy fines or initiate disciplinary measures against the organization. 2. Legal Recourse for Policyholders • Consumer Protection Laws : The consumer forums may approach to get relief for deficiency, in this case, undue delays while settling the claim. The Court may provide compensation, penalty on delayed payments, and compound interest. • Civil Court Action: When the claim is substantial or immeasurable delay results in significant loss, policyholders file breach of contract and damages in the civil court. • Insurance Ombudsman: Claim delay complaints from policyholders in India can be appealed before the Insurance Ombudsman. However, the process is extremely quick and cost-effective, not litigious. 3. Interest on Delayed Payments Generally, courts also direct the insurance companies to pay interest on the claim amount for the delay period so that unjustified delays are avoided and policyholders are compensated in respect of time value of money. 4. Bad Faith and Negligence • If an insurer is found guilty of bad faith, for instance, by denying a claim without valid reason or causing unnecessary delays to pressure the insured, courts may impose exemplary damages, which include punitive damages. • Compensation can also arise from careless actions by the insurer to process claims. 5. Redressal platforms and Alternative Dispute Resolution • IRDAI Grievance Cell: Aids to file complaints regarding delayed claims. • Lok Adalats (People's Courts): Provide for amicable and speedy settlement of insurance disputes. The law perceives undue delay in settling claims as a violation of the insurer's obligations, providing a range of remedies to safeguard the rights of policyholders. It is essential for policyholders to keep thorough documentation and to investigate regulatory, consumer, or judicial paths to effectively address their grievances. Hope this answer helps you.