- 07-Jun-2025
- Cyber and Technology Law
Software, particularly in today’s digital age, is increasingly being considered a product under product liability laws, though it presents unique challenges. While traditionally product liability has been associated with tangible goods, software can be subject to liability under certain circumstances, especially when defects or failures cause harm or financial loss. In India, software liability would typically fall under contract law, tort law, and consumer protection laws, depending on the nature of the issue.
If software is defectively designed or programmed, and this leads to damage (such as data loss, security breaches, or system failures), the manufacturer, developer, or distributor of the software could be held liable. A software defect can be the result of:
If the software was poorly designed and cannot perform its intended function or has inherent vulnerabilities.
If there are bugs, glitches, or coding errors that cause the software to malfunction, leading to harm or damage.
If the software has security flaws that can be exploited by hackers, causing harm such as data breaches or identity theft.
While software traditionally may not be classified as a physical product, in legal terms, it can be considered a product for liability purposes when it is sold, distributed, or used by consumers. This is because software is often a serviceable product that has specific functions and can cause harm if it fails.
Under contract law, when a consumer purchases software, they are entering into a contract with the software provider. If the software fails to meet the terms agreed upon (e.g., failure to perform, defective features, or breach of warranty), the consumer may be entitled to compensation.
Under tort law, if a defect in the software leads to damages (such as financial loss or harm), the software provider or developer could be held liable for negligence or failure to meet the required standards of care.
In India, the Consumer Protection Act, 2019 provides for protection to consumers in case of defective goods or services. Even though software is not always physically tangible, if it causes damage, the consumer could file a complaint under this law, especially when the software is defective or does not perform as expected.
If a consumer purchases software that does not work as advertised, causes data loss, or leads to significant business or personal harm, the manufacturer or developer could be held liable under the Consumer Protection Act.
If the software is purchased or downloaded from an online platform, the platform or seller might also be responsible for facilitating the resolution of claims related to the defective software.
Software companies often limit their liability through terms and conditions, which can protect them from lawsuits. However, these terms must still comply with consumer protection laws, and they cannot waive responsibility for gross negligence, fraud, or actions that endanger consumers' rights. For example, a clause that attempts to prevent a consumer from seeking redress for major defects or harm caused by software could be challenged in court.
A malfunctioning software application may cause a significant loss of valuable data, which can result in financial losses, especially for businesses.
Software vulnerabilities can lead to unauthorized access, data theft, or cyberattacks, causing harm to consumers or businesses.
Software that is intended to control equipment or devices (e.g., medical devices, industrial machines) can lead to malfunctions, endangering the safety of users.
If software fails in critical business functions, it can disrupt operations and cause significant economic damage.
If a software application mishandles user data, it could lead to privacy violations, exposing consumers to identity theft or fraud.
If the software fails to meet the specifications or promises made by the software provider, the consumer can file a claim under contract law for breach of contract. This is particularly applicable if the software was purchased with certain guarantees or warranties that it would perform as expected.
If a software defect results in harm (e.g., data loss, security breach, financial harm), the consumer can file a tort claim for negligence, claiming that the developer or manufacturer failed to take reasonable care in producing a safe and functional product.
Under the Consumer Protection Act, 2019, a consumer can file a complaint in Consumer Court if the software causes harm. The Act applies to both physical products and services, and software, which is treated as a product in this context, is protected under these laws. Consumers may seek compensation for losses incurred due to software failure.
If the software defect affects a large number of consumers, a class action lawsuit can be filed by a group of affected individuals. This is common when a particular software or software update causes widespread issues, such as a system crash or a security breach.
Regulatory bodies like the Ministry of Electronics and Information Technology (MeitY) in India oversee the development and distribution of software that may impact user safety, privacy, and data protection. If the software causes harm due to regulatory non-compliance, the consumer may seek intervention from such bodies.
Suppose a financial application used by thousands of users malfunctions and causes significant data loss. The company responsible for the software did not have adequate backups or fail-safes in place, leading to financial losses for users.
Discover clear and detailed answers to common questions about Personal Injury Law. Learn about procedures and more in straightforward language.
