Answer By law4u team
Under the Insolvency and Bankruptcy Code (IBC), homebuyers have been recognized as financial creditors in the event of a real estate developer or builder undergoing insolvency proceedings. This classification allows homebuyers to participate in the Corporate Insolvency Resolution Process (CIRP) and claim their dues, similar to other financial creditors, such as banks and financial institutions. However, homebuyers' role and claims are subject to specific guidelines and rights under the IBC.
Classification of Homebuyers under the IBC:
Homebuyers as Financial Creditors:
The Insolvency and Bankruptcy Code (IBC) treats homebuyers who have made advance payments for the purchase of property as financial creditors.
This classification was clarified by the Supreme Court in the Pioneer Urban Land and Infrastructure Ltd. vs. Union of India (2019) case, which held that homebuyers are financial creditors under the IBC. This enables them to file claims in the CIRP process and participate in creditor decisions, just like banks or other lenders.
The key distinction here is that homebuyers are not operational creditors but rather financial creditors, as they have paid a consideration upfront for a product (property) to be delivered in the future.
Participation in the CIRP:
As financial creditors, homebuyers can form part of the Committee of Creditors (CoC) in the insolvency process of the real estate company.
Homebuyers can vote on the approval or rejection of the resolution plan and play an essential role in determining the company's future, whether it will continue operations or be liquidated.
Their voting power in the CoC is determined based on the total value of their claims against the real estate company.
Rights in the Resolution Plan:
In case of a resolution plan, homebuyers have the right to be compensated for their unpaid dues, and they may receive a portion of the amount due under the resolution plan.
If a resolution plan is approved by the CoC, homebuyers may receive their promised property or a monetary settlement, depending on the terms of the plan.
Priority of Homebuyer Claims:
The claims of homebuyers are considered under the financial creditors category, but they do not have the same priority as secured creditors, such as banks that have a lien on the company's assets.
Homebuyers' claims are considered after the claims of secured creditors are settled. However, their claims rank higher than operational creditors, such as suppliers or service providers.
Impact of Insolvency on Homebuyers:
In case the resolution plan does not provide for the delivery of the property, homebuyers may not receive their homes but can instead claim a monetary settlement as part of the overall settlement with the company.
In the event of liquidation, homebuyers may receive a lower recovery rate, as the funds from the liquidation of assets are first used to pay off secured creditors before any claims by homebuyers are addressed.
Provisions under the Real Estate (Regulation and Development) Act (RERA):
While the IBC applies to homebuyers in insolvency situations, they can also avail of the provisions under the Real Estate (Regulation and Development) Act (RERA).
RERA provides additional protection for homebuyers in case of delays in property delivery or non-performance by builders. Homebuyers can claim refunds or compensation under RERA while also pursuing claims under the IBC for the outstanding payments.
Example:
Example 1:
A real estate developer faces insolvency, and the homebuyers who have made upfront payments for apartments under construction are recognized as financial creditors. These homebuyers are given a seat in the Committee of Creditors (CoC) and participate in voting on the proposed resolution plans. The CoC approves a resolution plan that involves the completion of the apartments and partial repayment to homebuyers who have made payments. Homebuyers receive possession of their properties after the resolution plan is implemented.
Example 2:
In a case where a builder has defaulted on delivering homes to buyers, the homebuyers approach the National Company Law Tribunal (NCLT) under the IBC. They are recognized as financial creditors and are included in the CoC. Despite the builder's insolvency, the CoC decides to opt for a liquidation process due to the inability to complete the project. Homebuyers receive a portion of their paid amount as part of the liquidation proceedings, though it is significantly less than their total dues.
Conclusion:
Homebuyers, under the Insolvency and Bankruptcy Code (IBC), are classified as financial creditors when a real estate company or builder faces insolvency proceedings. This allows them to participate in the Corporate Insolvency Resolution Process (CIRP) and have a say in the outcome, including voting on the resolution plan. However, their claims are subject to the approval of the Committee of Creditors (CoC) and are prioritized after secured creditors but ahead of operational creditors. Although homebuyers have the right to be compensated, their recovery depends on the outcome of the resolution process or liquidation.