Answer By law4u team
Convertible debentures are financial instruments that can be converted into equity shares at a later date, as specified in the terms of issuance. During insolvency proceedings under the Insolvency and Bankruptcy Code (IBC), the treatment of convertible debentures can be complex as they have both debt and equity characteristics. The classification and treatment of convertible debentures depend on the specific nature of the instrument and the provisions of the IBC.
Steps to Treat Convertible Debentures During Insolvency:
Classification as Debt or Equity: The treatment of convertible debentures in insolvency depends on whether they are considered debt or equity at the time of the insolvency resolution:
- Debt Component: If the convertible debentures have not yet been converted into equity, they are treated as unsecured debt. These debenture holders are classified as financial creditors, and their claims are considered during the insolvency resolution process.
- Equity Component: If the convertible debentures are converted into equity before or during the insolvency process, the holders are treated as equity shareholders. They will be paid only after all debts (both secured and unsecured) are settled.
Inclusion in the Resolution Plan: Convertible debenture holders who have not converted their debentures into equity will participate as financial creditors in the resolution process. Their claims will be addressed in the same way as those of other unsecured creditors. If the debenture holders opt to convert their debentures into equity, they may participate in the equity holders’ portion of the resolution plan, which typically comes after the repayment of secured creditors.
Voting Rights in Committee of Creditors (CoC): The treatment of convertible debentures also affects their ability to vote in the Committee of Creditors (CoC). If the convertible debentures are considered unsecured debt, they can participate as financial creditors and vote on the resolution plan. However, if they have been converted into equity, they would no longer have voting rights as creditors but would be treated as shareholders.
Impact of Conversion Option: If the convertible debentures are converted during the insolvency proceedings, the equity holders (former debenture holders) may not receive any payment until all creditors are paid in full. This ensures that equity holders bear the residual risk of the company’s insolvency.
Prioritization of Claims: The claims of convertible debenture holders will be prioritized according to their status as creditors or equity holders. As financial creditors, they are treated on the same level as other unsecured creditors, and if they hold equity, they will rank after all creditors in the liquidation process.
Legal Actions and Protections:
Insolvency and Bankruptcy Code (IBC): The IBC treats convertible debentures primarily as debt until they are converted into equity. Once converted, they are treated as equity, which is subject to payment after all other creditors are paid. This distinction ensures that convertible debenture holders have clarity on their rights during insolvency proceedings.
Resolution Plan Considerations: A resolution plan must address both the debt and equity components of convertible debentures. The resolution plan may propose the conversion of the debentures into equity, or it may offer a settlement based on their debt classification.
Debt Recovery Mechanisms: During insolvency, the recovery of funds by convertible debenture holders depends on their classification as creditors. As unsecured creditors, they are entitled to repayment after secured creditors. However, if they are converted into equity, their recovery is contingent on the success of the company’s restructuring.
Example:
If a company issues convertible debentures to investors, which can be converted into equity in three years, but the company enters insolvency proceedings before the conversion happens, the treatment will be:
- Before Conversion: The debenture holders will be treated as financial creditors and will participate in the resolution process. They will vote on the resolution plan and recover their dues as unsecured creditors.
- After Conversion: If the debentures are converted into equity during the insolvency process, the holders will lose their creditor status and become shareholders. They will only be paid after the debts of all creditors (secured and unsecured) have been settled, and they may receive nothing if there are insufficient funds.